DoAssignment study guide

20-D2.5k · Explain how wave speed depends on the medium

Learn to explain how wave speed depends on the medium through clear examples and targeted practice.

Alberta Grade 11 Physics

Oscillatory Motion and Mechanical Waves

The material carrying a wave affects how quickly its disturbance travels

The system in this lesson is a mechanical wave travelling through a material. A mechanical wave is a disturbance that passes through matter. The material is called the medium. Imagine a stationary observer beside the material. We call the direction in which the disturbance travels positive. Speed is a scalar: it tells how fast something moves but not its direction. Wave direction is stated separately. The main idea is that wave speed depends on the medium carrying the wave. A wave does not have one speed in every material.

What you will learn

  • Define a medium and describe how it affects the speed of a mechanical wave.
  • Explain why the same kind of wave can travel at different speeds in different materials.
  • Compare wave speeds using information about the wave and its medium without assuming every wave travels at one universal speed.

The medium is part of the wave situation

A medium is the material through which a mechanical wave travels. Air, water, and a solid object can each act as a medium. A disturbance is a change that can pass from place to place through that material. Sound travelling through air is one example of a mechanical wave.
The material does not simply sit outside the explanation of speed. Its properties affect how quickly a disturbance can be passed along. Different materials respond differently when disturbed. As a result, the same kind of wave can travel at different speeds in different media.
For example, sound travels through air, water, and many solids, but its speed is not identical in all three. This comparison is about the medium carrying the sound. It does not mean every sound wave in every situation has one fixed speed, or that the speed is set by the source alone.
  • A mechanical wave needs a material medium.
  • The medium affects the wave speed.
  • The same kind of wave can have different speeds in different media.

Compare media carefully

To explain a speed difference, first identify the kind of wave and the material carrying it. Then compare the stated speeds or use a qualitative comparison supplied in the problem. Do not assume a value for a material when none is given.
A comparison is clearest when the kind of wave is the same and only the medium changes. If a problem says a sound disturbance travels faster through one stated material than another, the explanation is that the media carry that disturbance at different speeds. The material properties matter to how quickly the disturbance is passed along.
Wave speed is not the same thing as the amount of energy carried, and this lesson does not use a drawing as evidence of a measured speed. A schematic is a simplified model. A measured value would require observations from a real investigation; hypothetical values are practice values only.
  • Compare like kinds of waves when discussing a change of medium.
  • Use only stated speed information; do not invent material values.
  • A schematic illustrates an idea but is not experimental evidence.

What a medium comparison can tell you

If two examples involve the same kind of wave in different media, a difference in speed shows that the medium matters. If the problem provides no numerical speed, the correct response may be qualitative: the media can carry the wave at different speeds, but the information given is not enough to calculate a particular value.
Keep the description focused on the wave’s travel through the material. A wave diagram may show a pattern, but the drawing alone does not establish how fast a real wave moved. Likewise, a proposed procedure or computer model is not the same as measured evidence from a completed physical investigation.
A useful explanation names the wave, names the medium or media, and states that the medium affects speed. If a numerical comparison is supplied, report which is faster and include the stated units. If no numbers are supplied, do not make up a numerical result.
  • A medium comparison can support a qualitative explanation without a calculation.
  • Numerical speeds require numerical information.
  • Keep claims about evidence separate from models and hypothetical examples.

Worked example

Sound in two different media

A question states that the same kind of sound disturbance travels through air and through a solid, and that it travels faster in the solid. Explain what this tells you about the medium.
  1. Identify the comparison
    The systems being compared are sound disturbances travelling through air and through a solid. The observer is stationary beside each medium. The positive direction is the direction each disturbance travels. The question gives a qualitative speed comparison, not numerical speeds.
  2. Explain the result
    The stated sound disturbance travels faster in the solid. This shows that the medium affects how quickly that kind of disturbance travels. It does not provide enough information to calculate either speed.
  3. Check the claim
    The conclusion matches the supplied comparison and stays qualitative. No unsupported numerical value or measured result has been added.
Answer: The medium affects sound speed. In the stated comparison, the sound disturbance travels faster through the solid than through air.
Check: The answer identifies both media and gives only the speed comparison supplied in the problem.

Worked example

A speed is not given

A mechanical wave travels through Material A. The problem says that Material B can carry the same kind of wave at a different speed, but gives no numerical values. What can you conclude?
  1. Define what is compared
    The systems are the same kind of mechanical wave travelling through Material A and Material B. The observer is stationary beside the media, and positive is each wave’s direction of travel. The unknown is the size and ordering of the two speeds.
  2. Separate known from unknown
    The statement tells us that the speeds differ. It does not say which material carries the wave faster, and it gives no numerical speeds. Those details cannot be inferred from the statement alone.
  3. State the supported conclusion
    The supported conclusion is that the medium can affect wave speed. More information is needed to decide which wave is faster or to calculate either speed.
Answer: The two speeds are different, so the medium affects the speed of this kind of wave. The information does not tell which medium gives the greater speed or provide numerical values.
Check: The conclusion does not add a direction or number that the problem never supplied.

Worked example

Use a stated hypothetical comparison

For practice, suppose a problem gives a hypothetical speed of 3.0 m/s for a wave in one medium and 5.0 m/s for the same kind of wave in another. Which medium carries the wave faster, and what is the lesson about the medium?
  1. Identify the system and direction
    The systems are the same kind of wave in two different media. The observer is stationary beside each medium. For each case, positive is the direction the wave travels. The given speeds are hypothetical practice values, not measured data.
  2. Compare the speeds
    Compare the stated magnitudes. The second speed, 5.0 m/s, is greater than 3.0 m/s. Therefore, the medium associated with 5.0 m/s carries this wave faster in the stated example.
  3. Check units and meaning
    Both values use metres per second, the SI unit of speed. The comparison is reasonable because the problem explicitly assigns different speeds to the same kind of wave in different media. It does not establish measured speeds for any named real materials.
Answer: The medium associated with 5.0 m/s carries the wave faster. The hypothetical comparison shows that the medium can affect wave speed.
Check: Both speeds have matching units, and the larger stated speed identifies the faster case.

Common mistakes and how to avoid them

A wave has one fixed speed in every material.
Correction: The medium affects the speed of a mechanical wave. The same kind of wave can travel at different speeds in different media.
If a question says speeds differ, we can tell which medium is faster.
Correction: A difference alone does not give the ordering. The problem must state which speed is greater or provide values.
A drawing proves a wave’s speed in a real material.
Correction: A drawing is a model. It is not measured evidence.
It is acceptable to invent a material speed when none is provided.
Correction: Do not invent data. Give a qualitative explanation or state what information is missing.

Lesson summary

  • A medium is the material through which a mechanical wave travels.
  • The medium affects how quickly a disturbance travels.
  • The same kind of wave can have different speeds in different media.
  • Use numerical values only when they are supplied, and label invented practice values as hypothetical.
  • A model or drawing is not measured evidence.

Check your understanding

Question 1

The same kind of wave is described in two media. A problem states that its speed differs between them but gives no other information. What can you conclude?
  1. The wave is faster in the first medium.
  2. The wave is faster in the second medium.
  3. The medium affects speed, but the faster medium is not identified.
  4. The wave must have the same speed in both media.
Show answer and explanation
The medium affects speed, but the faster medium is not identified.
The statement establishes that the speeds differ, but it does not identify which is greater.

Question 2

A hypothetical comparison gives speeds of 2.0 m/s and 4.0 m/s for the same kind of wave in different media. Which case is faster?
  1. The case with speed 2.0 m/s.
  2. The case with speed 4.0 m/s.
  3. Both cases are equally fast.
  4. The information cannot be compared because the values are hypothetical.
Show answer and explanation
The case with speed 4.0 m/s.
The larger speed is 4.0 m/s. The values can be compared as hypothetical practice values without claiming they were measured.

Question 3

What does a schematic drawing of a wave establish by itself?
  1. A measured speed in a real material.
  2. That the wave travels at the same speed in all media.
  3. A simplified picture of an idea, not measured evidence.
  4. Which medium carries the wave fastest.
Show answer and explanation
A simplified picture of an idea, not measured evidence.
A schematic is a model for communicating an idea. It does not provide experimental measurements.

Key terms

Mechanical wave
A disturbance that travels through matter.
Medium
The material through which a mechanical wave travels.
Disturbance
A change that can pass from place to place through a material.
Speed
How fast something travels. Speed has size but no direction.
Scalar
A quantity described by size alone, such as speed.
Schematic
A simplified drawing used to show an idea, not a record of measured evidence.

Continue through Physics 20

View the complete Physics 20 Alberta Grade 11 Physics curriculum and lessons

Tutor support for 20-D2.5k · Explain how wave speed depends on the medium

Working on 20-D2.5k · Explain how wave speed depends on the medium in Physics 20? Bring the question and your own attempt. In a live session, you can sketch the situation, name the quantities and check the units. Ask about the first step that does not make sense, then try a similar question yourself.

Explore physics tutoring · Request an eligible free 30-minute introduction. Your request is matched by subject and language; a tutor must accept before a time is confirmed.

برای مبحث 20-D2.5k · توضیح وابستگی تندی موج به محیط در درس Physics 20، سؤال و تلاش خود را همراه بیاورید. در جلسه می‌توانید موقعیت را رسم کنید، کمیت‌ها را نام ببرید و یکاها را بررسی کنید. راهنمای معلم فیزیک را ببینید یا جلسهٔ معارفهٔ رایگان ۳۰ دقیقه‌ای درخواست کنید. زمان جلسه پس از پذیرش معلم قطعی می‌شود.

About this lesson and its review

Published by DoAssignment. This reviewed lesson follows Alberta Grade 11 Physics (Physics 20), expectation 20-D2.5k. It is a study resource, not an official curriculum publication.

Before publication, content is checked for structure, mathematical or chemical notation, calculations, course boundaries, and readability. Errors can still occur, so corrections are welcomed.

Official curriculum reference

Report a correction or ask a question